Many schools are banning students from using cell phones in class, citing distraction and interference with learning as primary concerns. This stance is understandable, as the aim is to maintain an environment conducive to education. Despite these concerns, it’s worth considering the potential benefits of integrating mobile phones into classroom activities.
Not all are convinced that prohibiting phones in schools results in improved academic performance:
potential hot take but my school allowed phones no matter what year group you were in, had free wifi, and encouraged you to use your phones in class to find information and it was one of the highest performing schools in the country, banning just makes kids want it more https://t.co/9lOF91uvNk
— chloé 🌹 (@chlveh) October 2, 2023
In my own teaching experience, I’ve found that cell phones can significantly enhance learning. They serve as gateways to a wealth of information, interactive tools, and resources, instantly accessible at students’ fingertips. Instead of outright bans, a more nuanced approach involving a well-thought-out cell phone policy can strike the right balance. Such policies can delineate when and how gadgets may be used, thus harnessing their educational potential while curtailing their capacity to distract.
Imagine a classroom where cell phones become tools for interactive learning. Students could engage in real-time polls, access digital textbooks, and collaborate on projects with peers from around the world, all under the guidance of their teacher. Furthermore, mobile phones can aid in teaching digital citizenship, preparing students to navigate the complexities of the digital world responsibly.
Despite the number of school districts that have banned the use of cell phones in school, banning phones from school is not the right answer.
Obviously, most students are against these bans. Watch what they say about it in this video.
There are actually a number of reasons students should be allowed to use their phones in school. These include increasing the use of technology in the classroom, improving communication between teachers and students, helping students stay organized, and saving schools money by allowing students to access digital materials rather than relying so heavily on printed materials. Learn more about why students should be allowed to use cell phones in class in this article.
Developing a cell phone policy at school is essential to ensure students and teachers are able to enjoy the instructional benefits associated with using gadgets, while also ensuring that cell phones don’t become a distraction from learning.
Coming up with the right rules for using cell phones in school is essential. Below, I’ve put together some rules to get you started with creating your own cell phone policy for your school or classroom. Every situation is unique, so you will want to think about your specific students and modify these rules to help them meet the needs of your building.
If students violate the school’s cell phone policy, the following may occur:
**The administration reserves the right to adjust these consequences on a case-by-case basis if needed. For example, extreme behaviors that break the law or engaging in bullying or harassment of other students may result in suspension.
Having a cell phone policy in place is just the first step. Proper management of your policy and gadget use in your classroom is also essential. Use the tips below to help you manage cell phone use in your classroom. This will help ensure students are using mobile phones in ways that will benefit their learning, not ways that will detract from it.
A cell phone charging station and storage organizer can provide students with an acceptable place to keep their phones when they are not needed for instruction. You can add charging cables or allow students to bring their own chargers, to ensure their phones are ready to use when needed for instruction.
You can learn more about cell phone charging stations and storage organizers here. For those who prefer doing something with their own hands, I recommend finding some DIY ideas here.
To enhance the organization, label each pocket on the storage organizer with a number, corresponding to a student’s assigned seat or roll call number. Upon entering the classroom, students are to deposit their cell phones into their individually assigned slots.
This system not only facilitates an orderly way to manage the devices but also significantly reduces the temptation for students to use their phones during lesson time, thereby minimizing distractions. Furthermore, it streamlines the process of collecting and returning phones, making it efficient for both teachers and students, and maintains a focused learning environment.
Establish a classroom “cell phone jail” as a creative way to enforce the cell phone policy. Should a student be caught using their device during prohibited times, instruct them to surrender their phone to this designated area. The “jail” serves as a temporary holding spot for gadgets, ensuring that they remain untouched for the duration of the class.
This method not only reinforces the rules regarding cell phone usage but also acts as a deterrent for future infractions. It’s an effective classroom management tool that helps maintain focus and order, keeping students engaged in the lesson rather than their screens.
Implement a positive reinforcement strategy in your classroom to encourage adherence to the cell phone policy. Acknowledge and reward students who consistently comply with the rules regarding phone usage. This could be through verbal praise, a points system, or small privileges, like being first in line or a homework pass.
Such incentives not only promote a disciplined approach to mobile phone use but also foster an environment where positive behaviors are celebrated. This method shifts the focus from punishment to recognition, motivating students to self-regulate their phone activity and reinforcing the importance of being present and engaged during class time.
Sometimes students need to use their cell phones just for a moment to look up an unknown word, find a synonym, or review a topic. There may be times when you’re willing to permit such use and other times when you’re not, such as during a test.
Create a classroom hand signal that students can use to ask for permission without disrupting instruction or other students who are working. You can either give them a thumbs up to go ahead and use their phone or a thumbs down to let them know that now is not an acceptable time to have it out.
Consider implementing structured cell phone breaks during class sessions, allocating two to three minutes for students to freely use their devices. This brief respite not only acknowledges their desire to stay connected but can significantly diminish the urge to covertly check their phones.
By doing so, you’re likely to see a notable decrease in mid-lesson distractions, resulting in a more concentrated and engaged classroom environment. These scheduled pauses can serve as a compromise that upholds the integrity of instructional time while respecting students’ social needs, striking a balance between educational focus and digital life.
Incorporate cell phone usage into your curriculum thoughtfully by leveraging educational apps, facilitating research for projects, or engaging students with interactive polls during discussions. This method acknowledges the educational potential within students’ devices, turning them into tools for active learning. It offers a practical framework for students to interact with technology in a guided, purposeful manner.
By blending traditional teaching with modern tech, you create an interactive and dynamic classroom atmosphere, fostering digital literacy and responsible device management. Such intentional integration demonstrates to students the constructive capabilities of their cell phones, enhancing the educational experience.
Empower students by forming a classroom ‘Tech Support’ team, assigned to oversee the charging station’s operation, provide assistance for tech-related problems, and monitor appropriate cell phone usage during lessons. This initiative fosters a sense of responsibility and community, as team members take pride in maintaining an orderly and functional learning space.
It encourages a collaborative environment where students become stewards of their technology, developing practical skills and respect for their collective educational setting. This involvement can transform the way students perceive and use their devices, enhancing the classroom’s digital literacy and management.
The right cell phone policy at school can help students learn and reduce distractions. When students are able to use their phones appropriately during instruction, they can be powerful technological tools for researching, engaging with a lesson, providing feedback to peers, participating in classroom surveys, and more. The best cell phone policies also prevent students from pulling out their phones during inappropriate times, which can distract them from learning. Are you ready to use what you learned and begin crafting a cell phone policy that will work for your students?
Simona Johnes is the visionary being the creation of our project. Johnes spent much of her career in the classroom working with students. And, after many years in the classroom, Johnes became a principal.
Follow Simona:
